Ban Welsch Coach

[djarvik]

See, in my experience, Rabari, Neuwirth, and Welch are not on the same tier.
Welch is on his own tier beyond either of them. I don't see any reason to ban either of them....but I can see a reason to ban Welch.

I don't use Rabari, Welch, or Neuwirth, so I've got no bias there -- but in my experience from playing this game for almost a year now, Welch is far harder to play against than either Rabari or Neuwirth. Like I said in my other thread, Welch isn't even fun to play against. And to the person who keeps saying it's whining because you can't win -- hah. I can't win against a lot of guys....I'm just trying to have fun and play fun matches, and I can't do that against Welch. It makes me want to quit the tour when I have to play him 2 out of every 3 matches, because there's absolutely no fun involved.

Is Welsh the easiest to use out of the Tier 1 - Yes. Strongest - I don't think so. I think Rabbari potentially is stronger, assuming you stick to your game play.

I understand what you mean though, I also don't find it fun to play Welsh, at all. I rather play Rabbari.

[Tamthewasp]

I agree with evrything edlglide says. I just hope when I return in the future Drew Welch will be banned or toned down or just deleted from topspin altogether.

[LokiSharpShootr]

If welch gets banned im switching to a 0/9/11 Nagano with 80 wings, 81 speed and 66 power.

[Tamthewasp]

If welch gets banned im switching to a 0/9/11 Nagano with 80 wings, 81 speed and 66 power.

Now that sounds more like it. Not overpowered. Just about right

[Ary1g]

Julien Friedland = Silver Welsh. Should be much more balanced to the tour than Welsh. Here's stats to Julien:

0-0-20

Skill: Longer, better!

FH: 85
BH: 81
Serve: 40
Volley: 40
Power: 50
Stamina: 95
Speed: 85
Reflexes: 54

No reason to not ban Welsh!
All the polls show this very clear. If he's not banned, people will retire.

[o Sinna o]

If welch gets banned im switching to a 0/9/11 Nagano with 80 wings, 81 speed and 66 power.

lol

[xesco15]

if welch is banned, some people will retire. for example, i ll retire if welch is banned because its unfair. neuwirth and welch are almost similar in the style.
why do we ban neuwirth?
i agree with alex. we can restrict the fh and bh.
other posibility is that djarvik try to speak with 2k and i ve an idea:
welch can be a coach with 0-5-15 or 0-4-16 and then fh and bh would be 84/84 or 81/81.

[ELTXETXU]

If you ban Welch 99 percent people of the tour will play with neuwirth or rabary. Do you really think that would be funny??

All of this three coaches are overpowered in my opinion. I cant understand how rabary can reach every ball with a low speed, or hit incredibles angles with 70 BH, or serve and volley perfect. the same thing i could say about neuwirth. maybe Welch is easy to master, but it isn't more overpowered than the othr 2.

[Tamthewasp]

if welch is banned, some people will retire. for example, i ll retire if welch is banned because its unfair. neuwirth and welch are almost similar in the style.
why do we ban neuwirth?
i agree with alex. we can restrict the fh and bh.
other posibility is that djarvik try to speak with 2k and i ve an idea:
welch can be a coach with 0-5-15 or 0-4-16 and then fh and bh would be 84/84 or 81/81.

Welch n neuwirth similar? Have you been smoking some crystal meth?

[Fabada7]

Guys welch isnt op I can beat all the players that have welsch with rabari. Its true that players like murmeltier or likos play perfect with this coatch but is for their talent.


And Tamthewasp, Neuwirth and Welsch can make the same insane angles, I know this for my experience against zooloo.

[Tamthewasp]

A half a dozen coaches can make insane angles the only stat this is similar is fh 85 other than that so different.

[Tamthewasp]

I assume xesco is sharing his meth with you.

[DennieFR1908]

Guys welch isnt op I can beat all the players that have welsch with rabari. Its true that players like murmeltier or likos play perfect with this coatch but is for their talent.


And Tamthewasp, Neuwirth and Welsch can make the same insane angles, I know this for my experience against zooloo.

yep i have also played insane angles with Neuwirth, problem is it's much harder with neuwirth than it is with welch I can know cuz I play with both sometime.

[Chris ITST]

In the words of Andy 'The little bitch' Roddick.. I am baffled right now with all the hating on Welch, In my experience of actually playing against Rabari and using him, i find he is the one with the edge over Roman and Welch, without a shadow, i am finding with Welch that hes capable of taking down these boring power hore's but he in no way shape or form is a level above.

Infact i think its a fairly evenly balanced game TS4

Patel im surprised your complaining here i must say, what person would trouble you using a Welch? or is that someone is finding a way to neutrilize your serve and your not buying it

[ELTXETXU]

The most boring setup to play against is 98/98. So, ban it!!